“Regulation by enforcement has worked for them so far but now they have a decision against their main theories,” A decision out of the Southern District of New York that approved some crypto market practices despite claims from the federal agencies is already giving renewed hope for an industry long battered by securities enforcement. “The opinion is being regarded as a win for the industry because it adds nuance to the regulatory market,” said Winston & Strawn partner and digital assets and blockchain technology group co-chair Daniel Stabile in a webinar Friday morning. Stabile hailed the decision from U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres of the Southern District of New York District, which found some of the uses of the XPR token, created by Ripple Labs, would not be considered a security and was therefore precluded from Securities and Exchange Commission oversight. The decision is already impacting the long-struggling crypto market with those invested in XPR tokens seeing a nearly 70% increase in its value since Torres ruled Thursday. And while the judge did find the company could be subject to enforcement related to some of the digital asset sales, the lack of liability for other uses is what’s causing such a strong market shift. “Where investors knew they were buying tokens from Ripple, knew the money was going to be used by Ripple—in that case it did constitute a security, an investment contract, under the Howey test, and Howey was the correct framework,” said Winston & Strawn partner George Mastoris of the nearly 80-year-old test developed by the U.S. Supreme Court, which has long been used to define when an asset qualifies as a security and is therefore subject to federal enforcement. “Courts have found the existence of an investment contract even in the absence of Defendants ‘essential ingredients,’” wrote Torres in the partial grant of summary judgment. Put differently, the Howey test was intended to effectuate ‘[t]he statutory policy of affording broad protection to investors,’ protection that is ‘not to be thwarted by unrealistic and irrelevant formulae.’” That finding rejected Ripple’s argument “that all investment contracts must include post-sale obligations on the promoter and grant the investor a right to share in profits from the promoter’s efforts,” the Barack Obama appointee wrote. But when it comes to other sales, including programmatic sales, where the buyer had no way of knowing the sales were done pursuant a blind sale, Torres found the third prong of the Howey test wasn’t satisfied. “The application to secondary transaction markets, which Torres said she wouldn’t reach, seems a fairly straight line to draw to say those transactions may not actually constitute securities for purposes of the Howey analyst,” Mastoris said. “The focus is whether the purchaser’s money is being utilized by the issuer and whether they know their money is being paid for by the issuer, that’s the critical component and it’s missing.” This impact from tokens given to employees and the like, for someone’s labor for example, that’s not enough to qualify. “I expect there will be a lot of discussion around that finding,” Mastoris said. Notably the company’s due process arguments, that the agency failed to inform Ripple of their violations before enforcement, were denied, and that’s in line with other enforcement actions which have found the same. “The law does not require the SEC to warn all potential violators on an individual or industry level,” Torres wrote, citing Second Circuit precedent that asks “whether the law presents an ordinary person with sufficient notice of or the opportunity to understand what conduct is prohibited or proscribed, not whether a particular [party] actually received a warning that alerted him or her to the danger of being held to account for the behavior in question.” Still, the decision is one in a long line of otherwise bad legal decisions or settlements for the crypto industry. The SEC has a nearly flawless record of prosecutions and settlements against alleged crypto-related securities and fraud violations. Winston & Strawn partner Thania Charmani went as far as to hypothesize that the SEC will appeal and the Second Circuit may be very inclined to side with them. “In the meantime, the decision could still impact other courts,” she offered as a shining light. As influential as the Southern District of New York is, she said people could expect the Ripple decision to ripple through other cases in some ways. There’s also the hope that this ruling may inspire Congress to act. Sens. Cynthia Lummis, R-Wyoming, and Kirsten Gillibrand, D-New York, reintroduced an effort to address much of that uncertainty earlier this week. “This type of decision that changes the legal landscape could prompt congress to act sooner than later,” Charmani said. “Regulation by enforcement has worked for them so far but now they have a decision against their main theories.” Ripple was represented by Andrew Edward Goldsmith of Kellogg, Hansen, Todd, Figel & Frederick and Andrew J. Ceresney of Debevoise & Plimpton in the dispute.
36 Comments
Yed yousaf Shah
8/10/2023 04:43:09 am
You can earn free bitcoin through this site
Reply
Miller
8/12/2023 11:46:03 pm
I really enjoyed reading your blog post. It was informative and presented in a way that was easy to understand. <a href="https://glucofreezeurgent.com/special-today-digi/index.html#aff=Navjot100" target="_blank">click here</a> to learn more about the topic. Looking forward to your future posts!
Reply
Fayyaz
8/13/2023 12:47:42 pm
A cryptocurrency video course for beginners from an ex-Agora guru now publishing.
Reply
Devid warne
8/25/2023 07:29:25 am
Great work on your blog post! It was evident that you put in a lot of effort to provide valuable information. I appreciated the depth of your research and the way you presented the content. To gain further insights, <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532218&pub=2739076" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Devils
8/25/2023 09:50:09 am
Thank you for addressing the potential of offering online coaching or mentoring services in a specific field or area of expertise. It's a way to share your knowledge and make a difference. <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532218&pub=2749861" target="_blank">click here</a> for additional insights.
Reply
Devid
8/25/2023 11:26:18 pm
Your post showcases the power of passive income and the potential it holds for achieving financial independence. It's a motivating reminder to build assets that generate money even when we're not actively working. To delve deeper, <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532218&pub=1505224" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
David Luke
8/26/2023 01:14:50 am
All-in-one investing that's easy to use. Trade stocks and ETFs, invest in IPOs at IPO prices, or try automated investing. You can even start trading crypto. Plus, you’ll get up to $1,000 in stock when you fund a new account.†
Reply
Henry
8/26/2023 08:06:24 am
I appreciate the emphasis on ethical and sustainable money-making strategies that align with one's values and contribute positively to society. It's a conscious approach to success. For more information, <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532218&pub=2748003" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
david
9/7/2023 06:58:42 am
Ready to tap into the world of online market research? <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532150&pub=2754603" target="_blank">click here</a> and discover how to offer your insights and analysis to businesses in need.
Reply
Rocky Kori
9/7/2023 07:27:49 am
Your blog post was thought-provoking and well-argued. I enjoyed the way you presented your ideas and supported them with evidence and examples. To explore more, <a href="https://www.digistore24.com/redir/363385/Kori1975/" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Denoja
9/7/2023 06:55:40 pm
Your writing style is engaging and persuasive, making readers excited about the various money-making opportunities available. To learn more, <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532486&pub=2732253" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
sam
9/8/2023 09:17:22 pm
A cryptocurrency video course for beginners from an ex-Agora guru now publishing independently. High quality content and happy customers. Don't wait any longer - <a href="https://www.digistore24.com/redir/325658/Maheshkasar/" target="_blank">click here</a> to order this life-changing course!
Reply
Riki
9/9/2023 08:12:04 am
Your post discusses the potential of becoming an affiliate marketer and promoting other people's products or services for a commission. It's a way to make money without the need for your own products. <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532484&pub=2732392" target="_blank">click here</a> for more information.
Reply
lisa
9/14/2023 09:34:26 am
I enjoyed reading your insights on this subject. If you're curious to learn more, <a href="https://27e6akt7m4vz4eyzav7dit8n7q.hop.clickbank.net" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Steve b
9/18/2023 10:52:50 am
I'm amazed by the depth of knowledge you've shared in this article. It's truly enlightening. To delve deeper, <a href="https://ff5296rn422s1x8cn2w9hisv53.hop.clickbank.net" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Ashley
9/18/2023 10:31:44 pm
Looking for a reliable source of passive income? <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532213&pub=2745461" target="_blank">click here</a> to uncover a hidden gem that can generate consistent cash flow.
Reply
Thomas
9/19/2023 10:18:21 am
Are you a skilled translator? <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532655&pub=2690702" target="_blank">click here</a> and explore opportunities to offer your translation services to clients worldwide or work with translation agencies.
Reply
carol
9/20/2023 05:20:09 am
Want to make money through stock trading? <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532705&pub=2774722" target="_blank">click here</a> and gain insights into the world of investing and learn how to make informed trading decisions.
Reply
David
9/20/2023 05:37:31 am
Your post offers practical advice for leveraging the gig economy and platforms like TaskRabbit or Uber to offer your skills or services on a flexible basis, allowing you to make money on your own schedule. For more information, <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532705&pub=2774709" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Jack
9/21/2023 03:15:25 am
Genuine app to earn passive income.dont Miss this.Ready to monetize your programming skills? <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532682&pub=2774705" target="_blank">click here</a> and learn how to develop and sell software products or offer coding services to clients.
Reply
Sansel Manuel
9/21/2023 07:54:14 pm
I admire the depth of research evident in your post. It's well-supported and backed by credible sources. <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5529604&pub=2754277" target="_blank">click here</a> for additional information.
Reply
Smith
9/22/2023 02:05:56 am
I appreciate the emphasis on creating value and solving problems as a means to make money. It's a customer-centric approach that can lead to sustainable success. For additional insights, <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532708&pub=2776387" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
peter
9/25/2023 05:29:02 am
Your post offers practical tips for saving money and managing personal finances, creating a solid foundation for making money. It's a valuable skill set to develop. To explore further, <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532357&pub=2778805" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Martin
9/25/2023 08:58:20 am
Your explanations are easy to understand, even for beginners. If you're interested in more information, <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532213&pub=2779141" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
rocky
9/25/2023 10:44:58 am
Your blog post was really helpful and informative. I enjoyed reading your insights on the topic. If you want to learn more about this subject, simply <a href="https://thecryptocode.com/partners/" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Rocky
9/25/2023 10:23:16 pm
Your blog post was a valuable resource on the topic. I enjoyed the way you presented the information and the connections you made to real-life examples. To learn more, <a href="https://thecryptocode.com/partners/" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
James
9/27/2023 12:58:39 am
Thank you for sharing this insightful and informative blog post. I found the information you presented to be valuable and the explanations to be easy to understand. To explore further, <a href="https://www.highcpmrevenuegate.com/c6ym3xgbg9?key=a95b169b982856078bc10b9c5f5027c3" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
John
9/27/2023 07:01:52 pm
Your post explores the potential of monetizing a blog or website through affiliate marketing. It's a passive income stream that can be highly lucrative. To explore further, <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5528250&pub=2779185" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Aditya Prakash
9/29/2023 06:09:18 am
Your post discusses the potential of starting a membership site or online community and charging a recurring fee for exclusive content or access. It's a model for generating consistent income. <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532927&pub=2402567" target="_blank">click here</a> for more details.
Reply
Devid luck
9/29/2023 09:25:42 am
Thank you for discussing the potential of leveraging online platforms, such as Fiverr or Upwork, to offer freelance services and make money. It's a global marketplace for talent. <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532927&pub=2782340" target="_blank">click here</a> for more information.
Reply
9/30/2023 10:58:53 pm
Thank you for addressing the mindset around money and the importance of developing a healthy relationship with it. It's a crucial aspect of long-term financial success. <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532860&pub=2783452" target="_blank">click here</a> for more insights.
Reply
9/30/2023 11:01:28 pm
Looking for a way to make money through for online surveys? <a href="https://cdnnd.com/srv.html?id=5532213&pub=2783452" target="_blank">click here</a> and discover platforms that pay you for your opinions and feedback.
Reply
9/30/2023 11:04:06 pm
Turn your love for pets into a profitable venture. <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532927&pub=2783452" target="_blank">click here</a> and explore the possibilities of starting a pet-related business online.
Reply
10/1/2023 08:04:51 pm
Great work on your blog post! The content was well-organized and flowed smoothly. I found the information valuable and the suggestions you offered were practical. To explore more, <a href="https://www.digistore24.com/redir/325658/Rajjabshows/" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Jou
10/1/2023 09:36:10 pm
Your post emphasizes the importance of building a personal brand and establishing yourself as an authority in your field when pursuing money-making opportunities. It's a way to stand out and attract opportunities. For more details, <a href="https://cdndn.com/srv.html?id=5532954&pub=2781194" target="_blank">click here</a>.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
HISTORY
September 2023
Categories |